Peanut Butter Classic Shake price

Peanut Butter Classic Shake prices by city

Our Peanut Butter Shake is made with sweet vanilla soft serve, creamy peanut butter and finished with whipped topping and a cherry.

SizeNew York CityChicagoDallasAtlantaLos AngelesCalories
Mini$4.99$4.09$3.39$3.29$4.79430
Sm$5.69$4.89$4.19$3.99$5.19630
Med$6.49$5.49$4.79$4.59$5.89830
Lg$7.49$6.49$5.79$5.79$6.691320

Value: Mini 105 calories per dollar · Sm 129 calories per dollar · Med 151 calories per dollar · Lg 203 calories per dollar

SONIC has 5 live deals this week.

See SONIC deals

More Sweets at SONIC

The stores we checked

  • New York City: 3702 Queens Boulevard, Long Island City, NY 11101
  • Chicago: 1022 West Wilson Avenue, Chicago, IL 60640
  • Dallas: 1005 South Riverfront, Dallas, TX 75207
  • Atlanta: 1463 Moreland Avenue S.E., Atlanta, GA 30316
  • Los Angeles: 13351 Florence Avenue, Santa Fe Springs, CA 90670

Prices are from SONIC's own online ordering menu at these stores, before tax. Each franchise sets its own prices, so yours may differ.

Questions

How much is a Peanut Butter Classic Shake at SONIC?

$4.09 for a Mini at the median of our 5 SONIC stores, from $3.29 in Atlanta to $4.99 in New York City. Checked Nov 15, 2026.

What sizes does Peanut Butter Classic Shake come in?

Mini $4.09, Sm $4.89, Med $5.49, Lg $6.49.

How many calories are in Peanut Butter Classic Shake?

Mini: 430 calories; Sm: 630 calories; Med: 830 calories; Lg: 1320 calories, according to SONIC.

Is Peanut Butter Classic Shake cheaper with a deal?

SONIC has 5 live deals this week, such as Afternoon Happy Hour. See them on our SONIC deals page.

Get deals like these first.

Price-drop alerts in the MealSlash app. Free on iPhone.

Get the app